SCAMSSocial engineering, decoded First steps
← All stories
After a scamGuide

The Buyer Overpaid With a Check or Money Order. Now What?

You listed something for sale, the buyer sent a check or money order for more than the price and wants the difference back. How to check it and what to do now.

Woodcut-style print of a padded envelope torn open on a hallway table with a money order slip half out and a wrapped stroller box waiting by the door, black and terracotta ink on warm paper
Original editorial illustration. Not a photograph or evidence of an individual incident.

You are clearing space before the holidays, or selling a gift you will never use. A buyer agrees to your price without haggling, then a check or postal money order arrives for far more than you asked, with a polite note: please send back the difference, or pay “my mover” from the extra. If that envelope is on your table, or the money is already in your account, here is how this usually plays out and what to do at each stage.

How the week usually unfolds

The sequence below is pieced together from how the FTC and the CFPB describe this scam. Not every case matches, but if yours does, you can see where you are and what comes next.

  1. Day 1: A buyer messages about your listing, often without asking to see the item. There is usually a reason they cannot meet in person, and they offer to pay by check or money order.
  2. Day 3 to 5: The payment arrives. It is for more than the price, sometimes much more. The buyer apologizes for the “mistake” or explains that the extra covers a shipper who will collect the item.
  3. Same day: Messages start pushing you to deposit it and send the difference quickly, by wire, gift card, payment app or a money order of your own.
  4. A few days later: Your banking app shows the deposit as available. It feels settled.
  5. Weeks later: The bank tells you the item was counterfeit and takes the full amount back out of your account.

The FTC’s guide to fake check scams explains the gap between steps 4 and 5. Banks have to make deposited funds available quickly, but it can take weeks for a bank to figure out that a check is fake. Seeing the money in your balance does not mean the check was good. Fake checks, the FTC adds, can look just like real ones, even to bank employees.

Do not send the difference

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s answer on this exact situation says it is a common scam. Do not send any money to the buyer. Alert your bank or credit union and the marketplace where you listed the item. If the deposit is reversed, you may have to repay the bank, even if you already withdrew the money.

Checking a check versus a money order

The two arrive in the same envelope but get verified differently. Use contact details you find yourself, not anything printed on the item or in the buyer’s note.

What you received How to check it What to look for
U.S. Postal Service money order Call the Money Order Verification System at 1-866-459-7822, listed on the Postal Inspection Service’s money order flier Held up to light, a real one shows a repeating Ben Franklin watermark and a multicolored thread with “USPS” woven in. The amount is imprinted twice and should not look discolored or erased
A USPS money order over $1,000 Treat it as fake The same flier says domestic postal money orders cannot be more than $1,000 (international ones, $700)
Money order from another company Call the issuer using a number from its official website Ask whether that serial number was issued and for what amount
Cashier’s check or personal check Call the bank it is drawn on, using a number you looked up independently Ask whether the check is valid and in what amount. A number printed on a fake check can lead straight to the scammer
Anything you already deposited Ask your own bank to hold off treating it as cleared Ask whether it has been returned and how long they may take to know

The conversation with your bank

Call the number on your card or statement and ask for the fraud or deposit operations team. Something like this works:

“On [date] I deposited a [money order or check] for [amount] from a buyer on [marketplace]. It was more than the price, and the buyer wants the difference back. I think it may be counterfeit. Can you tell me its status, and can you note my account that I have not sent any money?”

Then ask three questions. Has the item been returned unpaid yet? If it turns out to be fake, when will the amount be taken back and will any fees apply? Is there anything I should not do with the funds in the meantime? The CFPB has a separate answer about overdraft fees after a fraudulent deposit is reversed, which is worth reading if your balance is tight.

Leave the deposited money untouched until the bank confirms in writing that the item is genuine. That can feel uncomfortable when it is showing as available, but it is the only way to be sure you are not spending money that will be pulled back.

If you already sent money back

Move fast on the payment you made, because each type has its own route. The FTC’s fake check guide says:

  • Wire transfer: call the wire company immediately, file a complaint and ask for the transfer to be reversed.
  • Money order you bought: contact the issuer to try to stop payment.
  • Gift card: tell the card’s issuer right away and ask about a refund.
  • Cryptocurrency: contact the company you used and ask it to reverse the transaction.

If you used a payment app or Zelle, report it to the app and to your bank the same day. Our guide to a stranger asking for a payment back covers how those reversals tend to go. If the buyer instead sent an email claiming your payment account must be upgraded before you can receive funds, that is a related trick described in our article on fake Zelle business-upgrade emails.

Be careful about one more thing. The CFPB warns that if a stranger sends you money and asks you to forward it, you could be acting as a money mule. If a buyer asks you to pass funds to a third party, stop and tell your bank.

Report it

The FTC recommends reporting fake check scams to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, to the U.S. Postal Inspection Service and to your state attorney general. The Postal Inspection Service fraud line on its flier is 1-877-876-2455, and you can also file at uspis.gov/report. Report the buyer’s profile to the marketplace too, with screenshots of the chat, a photo of the envelope and both sides of the check or money order. Keep the original item; your bank or an inspector may want it.

This scam shares its mechanics with job offers that send a check for “equipment.” If you know someone job hunting, our piece on cleared equipment checks explains why a “cleared” balance is not a safe one.

If you already shipped the item

Check the tracking right away. If you sent it by USPS with a tracking barcode and it is not yet out for delivery, you can ask for USPS Package Intercept. USPS says the service is not guaranteed, is requested by the sender, and costs $19.45 plus any postage, charged only if the item is intercepted. Other carriers have their own redirect options, so call them with your tracking number.

If a “shipper” or courier collected the item from your home, write down everything you remember: the vehicle, the time, any name or company given. Add that to your police report and your FTC report. Getting the item back may not be possible, but a clear report helps if the same buyer turns up again, and it is useful for any claim with your bank.

For the next sale, the simplest rule is to take payment only for the exact price, through the marketplace’s own checkout or in person, and to wait until your bank confirms a check is genuine before anything leaves the house.

Sources

Found a factual error or a source that has changed?

Send a correction →
Scam notes · email

Get new scam guides

Occasional, practical updates on emerging scam patterns and what to do next. No hype; unsubscribe at any time.