SCAMSSocial engineering, decoded First steps
← All stories
After a scamGuide

Paid a ‘New Mortgage Servicer’ From a Letter? What to Do Now

A letter or email said your loan was sold and gave new payment details. You paid, and your real servicer shows nothing. Steps for the money and the loan.

Linocut of a kitchen table with an opened envelope, a house key and a blank payment coupon slip, black and terracotta ink with heavy grain on warm paper
Original editorial illustration. Not a photograph or evidence of an individual incident.

A letter or email said your mortgage had been sold and that payments now go to a new company. It looked right, it had your loan number, and you paid. Now your real servicer says the payment never arrived, or you have started to doubt the letter. Two things need attention at once: the money that left, and the loan that may now look unpaid.

Start by working out where you stand. The answer decides who you call first.

Your situation First call Then
You paid in the last day or two by bank transfer, wire or online bill pay Your bank’s fraud line, to try to stop or reverse the payment Your real servicer, using the number on an older statement
You mailed a check that may not have been cashed yet Your bank, to ask whether a stop-payment is still possible Your real servicer
You paid weeks ago and the real servicer now says you are behind Your real servicer, to make the missed payment and flag the fraud Your bank, then the reports listed below
You have not paid yet but the letter worries you Your current servicer, from your last statement Nothing else until they confirm a transfer
The number to use

Take the servicer’s phone number from a monthly statement, coupon book or your online account that you opened before this letter arrived. Do not use any number, link or QR code from the letter or email. If the letter is fake, every contact detail on it leads back to the people who sent it.

What a real servicing transfer looks like

Mortgages do change hands, and the company that collects your payment can change too. That is why this scam works. The difference is that a real transfer follows a set routine under federal rules, and you can test a letter against it.

The CFPB’s answer on what happens when your mortgage servicer changes says both the old and the new servicer generally must send you a notice. The old one usually sends it at least 15 days before the transfer, and the new one within 15 days after, unless the two companies send a single combined notice. Under Regulation X, section 1024.33, that notice has to include specific details.

A real transfer notice includes What to check on your letter
The effective date of the transfer Is there a clear date, or only “effective immediately”?
A toll-free or collect number for the new servicer Does that number match what the new company lists on its own website, found by you?
A toll-free or collect number for the old servicer too A letter that mentions only the new company and never your current one is a warning sign
The date the old servicer stops accepting payments Does your current servicer confirm that date when you call?
A statement that the transfer does not change the terms of your loan A letter offering a lower rate, a modification or a “transfer fee” is not a routine notice

The FTC’s page on your rights when paying your mortgage adds one practical step: before you make the next payment, call your current servicer to confirm who the new servicer is. That single call is what separates a real transfer from a forged one, and it is worth making even when the letter looks perfect.

If the money has already gone

Treat the payment itself as a scam loss, separate from your mortgage. The FTC’s guide to what to do if you were scammed says to report a bank transfer to your bank or credit union immediately and ask them to reverse it. For a wire, report it to the wire transfer company, say a scammer tricked you, and ask for a refund.

When you call the bank, give the date, the amount, the receiving account details shown on the letter, and the words “I was tricked into paying an impostor posing as my mortgage servicer.” Ask for a claim or reference number and the name of the person you spoke with. Ask the bank to contact the receiving bank. Call the same day if you can. The longer money sits in the receiving account, the more time the people behind it have to move it on.

If you paid through your bank’s online bill pay, check whether the scammer’s account is now saved as a payee. Delete it, so next month’s payment does not go to the same place. If you set up an automatic payment from the letter’s instructions, cancel that too.

Protecting the loan while the money is chased

Here is the hard part. Your real servicer did not receive the payment, so on its books you may be behind. Some readers expect the 60-day grace rule to cover this. It covers something narrower.

The rule in section 1024.33(c) says that for 60 days after a real transfer, a payment that reaches your previous servicer on or before its due date may not be treated as late. The FTC describes it the same way: an on-time payment sent by mistake to the old servicer cannot draw a late fee or be reported late to a credit bureau. A payment sent to an account that never belonged to either servicer is not what the rule describes, and we found no federal rule that treats it as received.

So the practical order is:

  1. Call your real servicer today. Explain that you paid an impostor and give the date and amount. Ask what is now due, and by when, to avoid a late fee or a late report.
  2. Make the payment to the real servicer if you can, through its own website or app, or by the method on your genuine statement. Keeping the loan current protects your credit while the bank works on the lost payment.
  3. If you cannot cover a second payment, say so on the same call and ask what hardship options exist. Write down what they offer.
  4. Ask the servicer to note the fraud on your account, and ask whether anyone else has called claiming to be you or asked to change your contact details.
  5. Put any dispute in writing. The FTC says a written dispute (a “qualified written request”) should go to the servicer’s customer service address. The servicer generally must acknowledge it within five business days and correct the account or explain its decision within 30 business days. The FTC also says to keep making your regular payment rather than subtracting the disputed amount.

How did they know my loan number?

That is the question most people ask, and it is a fair one. We could not find a single public explanation for any particular letter. A deed of trust or mortgage is often recorded with the county, and lenders’ names appear in those records. Loan numbers can come from old paperwork, a breached account or an earlier phishing email. A letter that knows real details is still not proof that it came from your servicer.

Impersonation of servicers is documented. On July 24, 2025, Washington’s Department of Financial Institutions described a case in which someone used a real servicer’s logo and posed as one of its employees to offer a loan modification with a deadline. The real servicer said the offer did not come from it. The agency pointed to an email address unrelated to the company and urgent language as warning signs, the same features many fake transfer letters share.

Report it, in this order

  • Your bank and your real servicer, as above. They are the only two that can move money or fix the account.
  • IC3.gov, the FBI’s complaint center, with the receiving account details, the letter or email and the payment record.
  • ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
  • The CFPB complaint portal, if your servicer will not correct the account, charges fees you dispute or does not answer your written request.
  • Your state’s financial regulator, which licenses servicers in many states. Washington’s alert lists the CFPB at 1-855-411-2372 alongside the FTC and IC3.

Keep the envelope or the full email, including the sender address. If the letter came by mail, the Postal Inspection Service takes reports of mail fraud.

Related situations

A similar trick reaches businesses as a vendor email announcing new bank details, and the bank conversation is much the same. If the mailing you received was selling something rather than redirecting your payment, see our guide to home-warranty letters dressed up as lender notices. And if someone seems to be using your property records more broadly, our piece on an impostor trying to sell land explains county recorder alerts.

Getting the payment credited and moving on

Expect the bank’s answer to take time, and expect it may be partial. Write down every call. When the bank decides, ask for its decision in writing. If money comes back, apply it to the next real payment and keep the paperwork together with your mortgage records.

For the months ahead, set up a simple check: any change to where you send your mortgage payment gets confirmed by calling the number on a statement you already trust. Real transfers survive that call. This scam does not. It caught you because you were trying to pay on time, which is nothing to be embarrassed about.

Sources

Found a factual error or a source that has changed?

Send a correction →
Scam notes · email

Get new scam guides

Occasional, practical updates on emerging scam patterns and what to do next. No hype; unsubscribe at any time.