Switched to a Health Plan You Never Chose? Restore Coverage
After a sales call in open enrollment your plan changed without your say. What the FTC's Oct 29 alert covers, who to call, and how CMS has restored coverage.

You took one call about health plans, perhaps just to hear a price. Weeks later your insurer, your broker or your premium is not what you chose. This is how to find out what changed, who to call to restore the right plan, and what the federal side has and has not said about it.
Open enrollment for the Health Insurance Marketplace runs November 1 to January 15, and the FTC noted in an October 29, 2026 consumer alert that people see a flood of ads and sales calls in that window. The same day, according to the FTC’s press release, FTC staff sent warning letters to 25 companies that market or generate sales leads for healthcare plans.
A correction worth making early: those letters concern misleading advertising claims. The press release does not mention unauthorized enrollment or plan switching, and the letters allege no wrongdoing by any recipient. They are a signal about what the FTC is watching, not an account of what happened to you.
What we know, and what we do not
| Known from the sources | Not established |
|---|---|
| The FTC says ads can promise comprehensive coverage that actually offers limited benefits, that medical discount cards are marketed as if they were insurance, and that some ads imitate the government or well-known insurers | How often a lead-generation call leads to a plan change. We found no FTC figure |
| CMS has said that consumers who think an agent or broker switched them or enrolled them without consent should call the Marketplace Call Center | Whether your change came from a broker, an error, or something you agreed to on a call you do not recall |
| CMS has described restoring enrollment for verified unauthorized switches | How quickly a restoration happens in your case |
Step 1: find out what changed
- Log in to your Marketplace account by typing HealthCare.gov (or your state marketplace’s address) yourself. Look at the current plan, effective date and the agent or broker listed.
- Check mail and email for a new insurer’s welcome letter or card. Check your bank for a premium draft you did not expect.
- Write down the date, the number that called and anything you said yes to. Do not guess if you cannot remember.
The Marketplace Call Center, 1-800-318-2596 (TTY 1-855-889-4325). The FTC’s October 29 alert names this number as an official starting point, and a CMS statement of May 6, 2024 directs people who think an agent or broker changed their plan without consent to call it. If your state runs its own marketplace, use that marketplace’s contact details instead.
Step 2: say what happened, in plain terms
Tell the call center that you did not authorize the change, or that you do not recall agreeing to it, and name the plan you want. CMS has described the process this way: it first verifies that the switch was unauthorized and identifies the plan you wanted; the insurer for that plan is directed to restore your enrollment as though it was never ended, and to cover eligible claims and apply your cost sharing toward deductibles and annual limits. You and the IRS receive corrected tax forms so the switch does not cause adverse tax consequences.
That description comes from a 2024 statement, so ask the representative what applies now and record the date, the name and a reference number for each call. Make the call yourself rather than leaving it to the person who may have made the change.
Step 3: protect your care while it is sorted out
- If you have an appointment or prescription soon, tell the provider about the coverage question and ask what they need from you.
- Keep every card, letter and Explanation of Benefits you receive, for both plans.
- If you have been charged a premium for a plan you did not choose, ask the insurer about refunds when the call center confirms the problem.
- If you receive tax-credit-related notices, keep them; CMS says corrected forms are supposed to follow a verified unauthorized switch.
What if the plan was not real insurance?
Some calls sell products that look like health coverage. The FTC’s alert lists limited-benefit plans and medical discount cards marketed as insurance. If you paid for one, ask the seller for its written terms and a cancellation process, then compare it against what Marketplace coverage would cover. Report misleading ads or an illegal prerecorded robocall to ReportFraud.ftc.gov; the FTC says robocalls with prerecorded messages marketing health insurance are illegal.
If you paid by card or bank transfer for something that was misrepresented, use the sequence in the FTC’s what to do if you were scammed. For a card, the CFPB sets a deadline: written notice within 60 calendar days after the charge appeared on your statement.
What not to do
Do not give your Social Security number, income or Marketplace login to a caller who contacted you. The FTC says to start at HealthCare.gov or the call center number. If a stranger offers to “fix” the change for a fee, stop; the Marketplace call center is the official route. Our guide on Medicare open enrollment calls covers the same pressure for people on Medicare, and the benefit-boost fee shows the fee-first pattern.
Questions for the call center
- Which plan am I enrolled in now, and with which effective date?
- Which agent or broker is attached to my enrollment, if any?
- Can this be handled as an unauthorized change, and what is the reference number?
- Will my previous plan be restored as though it never ended, and how are claims in the gap treated?
- What happens to my tax-credit information and forms?
These mirror the steps CMS described in 2024. Not every answer will arrive on the first call; ask the representative to tell you what to expect and by when, and call back with your reference number if you hear nothing.
Keep a log
Write down every call: the date, time, representative name, what was said and the reference number. Keep copies of letters from both insurers. If you later need to explain a gap or an unexpected bill, a log is far more persuasive than a recollection. Open enrollment is busy, and clear notes are the easiest way to keep your case from getting lost.
The first 24 hours, first week and first month
| When | What to do |
|---|---|
| Day 1 | Log in to your Marketplace account and note the current plan and agent. Call the Marketplace Call Center, 1-800-318-2596 (TTY 1-855-889-4325). Ask for the case reference number |
| Days 2 to 7 | Contact the new insurer to confirm what it has on file, and your previous insurer to confirm your old coverage status. Tell any provider with an upcoming appointment |
| Weeks 2 to 4 | Check that the correct plan shows as active. Follow up with your reference number if it does not. Keep every card, letter and bill from both plans |
| At tax time | CMS has said you and the IRS receive corrected tax forms after a verified unauthorized switch. Check that what you receive matches the coverage you actually had |
A script for the call
“I enrolled in [plan] for this year. I recently found that my enrollment shows [other plan] under [agent or broker name]. I do not recall authorizing this change. I want to report it as an unauthorized change and have my [original plan] restored. Can you check my enrollment history, tell me what happens to my claims and premiums in the meantime, and give me a reference number?”
If you did take a call from a marketer but are unsure what you agreed to, say that too: “I spoke to a company by phone about plans, but I did not understand that it would change my enrollment.” The representative can only work with what you tell them, and an honest account is more useful than a firm denial you cannot support.
What-if branches
- You already used the new plan. Tell the call center and the insurer. CMS has described directing the insurer of the plan you wanted to restore your enrollment and cover eligible claims; ask how claims under the other plan are handled.
- You do live in a state-run marketplace. The federal call center number is for HealthCare.gov. Use your state marketplace’s contact information; the process may differ.
- You think you did agree on the call. You can still ask what the call center can do. If a product was not insurance, the FTC’s alert lists limited-benefit plans and discount cards marketed as insurance; ask for the written terms and a cancellation process.
- Your premium was drafted from your bank. Contact the insurer first. If you paid by card or bank transfer for something misrepresented, the FTC’s what-to-do page lists the first call for each method.
- Someone offers to fix it for a fee. The Marketplace call center is the official route. Treat any request for payment to “correct” your enrollment as a warning sign.
What to expect afterwards
CMS’s 2024 statement described the call center first verifying that a switch was unauthorized and identifying the plan you wanted, and then directing the insurer to restore your enrollment as though it was never ended. It does not give a time frame, and we did not find a current one. Plan for a stretch of weeks in which two insurers have records for you, and keep paperwork showing that you asked for the restoration.
Open enrollment ends January 15, according to the FTC’s alert, so if the issue involves choosing a plan for next year, ask the call center what deadlines apply to your correction. A restored enrollment is only helpful if the plan you want is the one you intended for the coverage year in question.
Sources
- FTC consumer alert, “Seeing lots of ads for health insurance plans during open enrollment? Read this” (October 29, 2026)
- FTC press release on warning letters to healthcare plan marketers (October 29, 2026)
- CMS, Statement on agent and broker Marketplace activity (May 6, 2024)
- FTC, What to do if you were scammed
Found a factual error or a source that has changed?
Send a correction →

