Your Mailed Holiday Check Was Stolen and Rewritten: Next Steps
A check you mailed was cashed for a new amount or payee, or a check meant for you never came. Who to call first, the reporting deadline, and what to keep.

You mailed a check for a gift, rent or a holiday donation, and your bank statement shows it cashed for a much larger amount, or paid to a name you have never heard of. Or a relative’s check to you never arrived. Either way, the clock that matters most is your bank’s reporting window.
Start here: whose check is it?
| Your situation | Who acts first | Your first call |
|---|---|---|
| You wrote the check and it cleared for a different amount or payee | You, as the account holder | Your bank’s fraud line, today |
| You wrote the check and it has not cleared, but the recipient never got it | You | Your bank, to stop payment; then tell the recipient |
| Someone mailed you a check that never arrived | The person who wrote it | Call them so they can contact their bank |
| You see new checks clearing that you never wrote, on your own check stock | You | Your bank; ask about closing the account |
Check washing is the term for what usually happened. FinCEN, the Treasury’s financial crimes bureau, described it in a February 27, 2023 alert issued with the U.S. Postal Inspection Service: thieves use chemicals to remove the original ink, replace the payee and often the dollar amount, and may copy and print more washed checks to use later or sell. The same alert says criminals steal personal checks, business checks, tax refund checks and government benefit checks from the mail.
You did nothing unusual by mailing a check.
The OCC’s consumer site, HelpWithMyBank.gov, says you generally have up to 30 days from the statement date to tell your bank about an unauthorized signature or alteration on a check. It adds that periods vary by bank and state, and that your deposit account agreement sets the rules. Report as soon as you see it.
If you wrote the check and it cleared wrong
- Call your bank’s fraud department using the number on your card or statement. Say a check you wrote was stolen from the mail and altered, give the check number, the amount you wrote and the amount that cleared.
- Ask for an image of the cashed check, front and back. It shows the new payee and where it was deposited, which helps the bank and investigators.
- Follow up in writing. Send a short letter or secure message with the same details and keep a copy. Ask the bank which deadline it is applying and whether it needs an affidavit.
- Ask about the account itself. HelpWithMyBank suggests that if there are multiple forgeries, such as from stolen checks, you may want to consider closing the account. Washed checks show your account and routing numbers, so ask whether a new account number makes sense.
- Stop payment on other checks in transit. If you mailed several checks that week, list them and ask the bank to watch or stop them, then reissue by another method.
Report it to the people who investigate mail theft
The U.S. Postal Inspection Service handles mail theft. Its reporting page takes suspected mail theft and other mail-related crimes online, and you can call 1-877-876-2455. Have the date, time and place you mailed the check ready, and note whether you used a blue collection box, your home mailbox or a post office counter.
- Police: File a report where you live. Banks sometimes ask for the report number.
- FTC: Report at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
- IdentityTheft.gov: If anything beyond the check was taken, such as statements or account letters, the FTC’s scam recovery page sends you to IdentityTheft.gov for a recovery plan.
What to say when you call the bank
Fraud lines are busy in December, and a clear opening gets you to the right team faster. Something like this works:
“I’m calling to report an altered check. I wrote check number [number] on [date] to [payee] for [amount] and mailed it on [date] from [place]. My statement shows it paid on [date] for [amount] to [different name]. I did not authorize that payee or amount. I’d like to open a fraud claim, get an image of the front and back of the cashed check, and know where to send written notice and whether you need an affidavit. Can you also give me a claim number and tell me what deadline applies under my account agreement?”
Write down the representative’s name, the time, the claim number and anything they promise. If they tell you the claim is late or does not qualify, ask them to send that decision in writing with the reason.
Signs that more than one check was taken
A single washed check is sometimes the visible part of a larger theft. FinCEN’s alert notes that washed checks may be copied and printed for later use or sold to other criminals, which means a check you wrote weeks ago can resurface as several new ones. Watch for these over the next few statements:
- Check numbers out of sequence, or numbers you have not reached yet in your checkbook.
- Payees you do not recognize, especially individuals rather than businesses.
- Mobile deposits or ATM deposits of your checks in other states.
- Other expected mail that never arrived around the same dates, such as statements, a new card or a tax document.
If you see any of these, tell your bank right away and add the details to your USPIS report. If statements or account letters went missing too, treat it as possible identity theft and use the FTC’s IdentityTheft.gov steps.
A realistic timeline
| When | What happens |
|---|---|
| Day you notice | Call the bank, request the check image, stop other checks in transit |
| Within a few days | Written notice to the bank, USPIS report, police report |
| Following weeks | The bank investigates; it may ask for an affidavit or for the police report number. Keep notes of every call |
| By your bank’s deadline | Make sure the bank has your written notice; HelpWithMyBank’s general guide is 30 days from the statement date, but your agreement controls |
| Afterwards | Watch statements closely for further checks on the same account, and check your credit reports if other mail was taken |
“Altered” or “counterfeit”? Ask how the bank classifies it
Banks sometimes treat a check that was washed and rewritten differently from a check that was printed from scratch using your account details. The classification can change which rule or deadline the bank applies under your account agreement. If the bank says your claim falls outside a window, ask it to identify the specific provision in your deposit agreement, in writing. If you think the bank mishandled your claim, HelpWithMyBank.gov takes complaints, and you can also file a complaint with the CFPB.
If the check was meant for you
You cannot stop payment on a check you did not write, so the writer has to act. Call them, explain that the check never arrived, and ask them to check whether it has cleared. If it has, the bank fraud steps above are theirs to take, and they should report to USPIS too. If it has not, they can stop payment and send the money another way.
Holiday cards are a particular target because they often hold checks. If grandparents or relatives usually mail money in December, a quick call now about a different method can save a difficult conversation later.
The replacement-check problem
Once a check has been stolen, the natural instinct is to mail a new one quickly. Wait a moment. If your account number is now in the wrong hands, a new check from the same account carries the same risk. Ask your bank whether to move to a new account first, and in the meantime pay through your bank’s own bill pay, a transfer to someone you know, or hand delivery. If a donation was involved, give through the charity’s own website rather than a link in an email; our guides to unexpected recurring donations and offers to recover lost money cover two follow-on problems people sometimes meet.
Scale helps explain why banks take these reports seriously. FinCEN’s alert says that from March 2020 through February 2021 the Postal Inspection Service received 299,020 mail theft complaints, a 161 percent increase on the year before, and that suspicious activity reports on check fraud filed by financial institutions passed 680,000 in 2022. Your report adds to the picture investigators use.
Sources
- FinCEN, Alert on Nationwide Surge in Mail Theft-Related Check Fraud Schemes, FIN-2023-Alert003 (February 27, 2023)
- OCC HelpWithMyBank.gov, Check forgery time limit
- U.S. Postal Inspection Service, Report
- FTC, What to do if you were scammed
Found a factual error or a source that has changed?
Send a correction →

